Pettifoggery

Pettifogger - 1) a lawyer whose methods are petty, underhanded, or disreputable 2) one given to quibbling over trifles

Name:
Location: The Wild and Woolly West, United States

Monday, October 30, 2006

Things You Should Have Learned in Law School

Legal Research and Writing is often called the simultaneously the least important and the most important class in law school. It's the least important, because it's not part of the substantive 1L curriculum of Torts, Contracts, Property, Civil Procedure, Criminal Law, and Constitutional Law. It's not worth as many credits as the substantive courses. At some schools, there's two separate GPAs, one with all courses, and one excluding Legal Research and Writing. The Public Legal Intellectual Glossary, which is a wonderful glossary for the slang used among law students and legal geeks, considers legal research and writing professors one rung below janitors in the law school hierarchy. So Legal Research and Writing gets no respect. However, it's also one of the most important classes, because no matter what your practice is, the material is relevant. Even if your jurisdiction doesn't use the dreaded Bluebook (California accepts the Bluebook, but all the documents I've come across use the California Style Manual), Legal Research and Writing teaches you the basics of lawyering: how to research, how to write a brief and how to make an oral argument. Courtesy of the Legalwriting.net blog comes this gem from Politico v. Promus Hotels, Inc., 184 F.R.D. 232 (E.D.N.Y. 1999) about the importance of Legal Writing and Research:

The complaint should state only enough facts, in simple, concise, and direct terms to show what plaintiff's claims are and to allow defendant to respond. The statements should be short because "[u]nnecessary prolixity in a pleading places an unjustified burden on the court and the party who must respond to it because they are forced to select the relevant material from a mass of verbiage." 5 Wright & Miller, § 1281. It is simply not fair to the court or to the defendant to require a pleading in response to the amended complaint which plaintiff has submitted. A complaint should not be a preview of counsel's argument to the jury at the end of the case.

The complaint should not plead evidence. Such information is available through discovery. Geisler v. Petrocelli, 616 F.2d 636, 640 (2d Cir.1980).

Mentioning affirmative defenses such as contributory negligence is unnecessary in a complaint. See Fed.R.Civ.P., Advisory Committee Notes, 1963 amendment, Form 9 (1998).

Plaintiff's amended complaint is anything but concise. Most of the verbiage could be deleted because it pleads evidence. Moreover, the amended complaint is needlessly repetitive.

A complaint should avoid unnecessary facts, descriptive terms, and repetitions. It should not use argumentative language, or characterizations such as "cynical," "haughtily," or "much too little too late." The guiding principle should be to give clear notice of each claim to enable the defendant to respond to each claim.

The complaint should, as much as possible, avoid multiple allegations per paragraph. Though paragraphs containing single allegations are not mandated by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 10(b), see 5 Wright & Miller, § 1324, given the stubbornly prolix nature of plaintiff's complaint, the court repeats the directions it gave in its previous order: "plaintiff's counsel is directed to plead the allegations in separately numbered paragraphs, each containing a single allegation of which the defendant will either admit or deny, and each allegation stated in the simple, direct, and concise language required by Rule 8."

To assist plaintiff's attorney, the court is enclosing a copy of a sample pleading in a negligence case taken from 2 James Wm. Moore, Moore's Manual-- Federal Practice Forms, Form No. 10:86G (1998). The court also recommends that plaintiff's attorney study William Strunk, Jr. & E.B. White, The Elements of Style (3d ed.1979).


In all fairness, equal blame must be laid on this unfortunate attorney's lack of attention in Civil Procedure as well as Legal Research and Writing. When I took Civil Procedure, in addition to numbing of the mind that is Pennoyer v. Neff, International Shoe, and Asahi Metal Industries, extensive time was spent on the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and how to draft a complaint. Though seriously, what happened? I've looked up the attorney on Westlaw and he ain't a dummy. Villanova University School of Law, class rank 14/100, Moot Court, full scholarship. Heck of a lot better than me. Since New York is a code pleading state, meaning that you put in everything as statute requires, I'm going to guess that the plaintiff's attorney submitted a New York-style code pleading to a federal court, which requires notice pleading. As per Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 8, a notice pleading is a "short and plain statement" that is basically just enough to give notice to the other side of what is being alleged. However, that doesn't explain the use of loaded language such as "haughtily" or "much too little too late." Nor does it explain why the judge would recommend Strunk and White, unless it was for Strunk's famous cry of "Omit needless words." Must have been a law clerk who drafted it, and I've already commented on the danger of relying upon law clerks.

P.S. I much prefer the British style of placing periods inside or outside the quotations depending on the usage of the quotations. For example, if the ending punctuation is not a part of the quoted sentence, it should not be included within the quotes. I consider the quote a self-contained unit, placed within the larger sentence—a box within a box. (Yay! An usage of the em dash. Will an interrobang be next?) American usage is that periods must always be inside the quotation marks no matter what. The quote is no longer self-contained and leaks out to muss up the rest of the sentence. I'm also a big fan of the serial comma, as are Strunk and White. I do not believe the Bluebook has a preference in regards to the serial comma or not, though as a style manual it is hypertechnical enough to have a cite format for the works of Shakespeare. I should somehow work the following into my next brief. "First thing we do, kill all the lawyers." William Shakespeare, The Second Part of King Henry the Sixth act 4, sc. 2.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home