More Things You Should Have Learned in Law School
I actually do recall a lecture in my Legal Research and Writing class about writing letters. I do wish I recall more of the class, because letters do seem to get lawyers in trouble. In the age of the Internet, to become a laughingstock in the world only requires a simple click on the forward button. There has been a series of stories of lawyers writing e-mail and the communications biting them in the ass. And yes, I'm aware of the irony of warning about writing things down that will get you in trouble, while writing all of this on a blog, that could possibly get myself in trouble.
I've read stories of law clerks hooking up with associates. Particularly notorious are stories of young female law clerks working over the summer seducing senior partners, or is that the other way around? I usually consider such stories as reliable as locker-room talk since they mainly come from message boards such as Greedy Associates. However, a New Zealand law clerk removed all doubt when he e-mailed an associate at another firm with "At the end of the day we are both really busy and don't have time for anything else but a bit of good-hearted action . . . I thought you were hot and was sure you'd be a rocket in the sack, which I think you would be . . .." Do men honestly think that propositioning women in such a forward and vulgar manner would cause them to respond in the affirmative? Maybe that's what I'm doing wrong with women; I haven't made clear my desire to make the beast with two backs. William Shakespeare, Othello act 1, sc. 1.
For something stateside but still an example of how not to write e-mail, there was the infamous case of the exchange between two lawyers over a declining of a hiring offer. Diana Abdala took a year off after she graduated from Suffolk University Law in 2004. Then she started looking for a job and answered a Craigslist advertisement by William Korman for a new associate. Korman was going to hire two associates instead of one, so he had to lower his offer to her by $5,000. Korman said Abdala agreed to work for him despite the lower amount of money. Abdala said she made no agreement and was still pondering the offer. Anyways, Abdala sends an e-mail declining the offer because it won't support her and the lifestyle to which she is accustomed. Korman replies by e-mail that he had already created computer accounts and business cards for her and finds her behavior unprofessional. Rather than leave it at that, Abdala trots out a 1L answer that a contract should be in writing and that a real lawyer would not have acted in reliance until he had an written agreement. I guess she missed that part in Contracts about promissory estoppel and detrimental reliance, and what contracts the Statute of Frauds actually requires to be in writing. Korman, who has been a member of the bar for over a decade and is a former prosecutor was insulted at being called not a real lawyer, wrote back an e-mail chiding her for the law school answer and informs her that pissing off lawyers is not a good idea, particularly when she might be encountering those lawyers on a regular basis. Abdala's answer would make William Strunk proud, except for the misspelling: "Bla bla bla." Korman decides to forward this e-mail exchange and it gets forwarded and forwarded, so it spreads and makes the front page of the Boston Globe, and even Nightline. Sacha Pfeiffer, 2 E-mailers get testy, and hundreds read every word, BOSTON GLOBE, Feb. 16, 2006, at A1 available at 2006 WLNR 2693026; Nightline (ABC television broadcast Feb. 17, 2006). The Wall Street Journal Law Blog has the actual text of the e-mail exchange for the curious. She filed a complaint with the Massachusetts bar claiming that Korman forwarded their communication and was threatening her. To the Boston Globe, Abdala described herself as a "trust fund baby", and she certainly sounds like one. On the other hand, Korman was similarly immature by snidely responding back and forwarding their conversation to third parties. Any publicity is good publicity, but I think both parties are for the worse by having the e-mail exchange published.
By the way, the online commentary over the Abdala-Korman exchange again brings up the ugly head of law school ranking elitism. Harriet Miers went to SMU for law school, so she must have been too stupid to go a top tier law school, even if Chief Justice Warren Burger went to St. Paul College of Law, now William Mitchell College of Law, and Associate Justice Thurgood Marshall went to Howard University. Both of those are fourth-tier law schools. Suffolk is a fourth-tier law school, so obviously Abdala can not be brilliant though she she finished high school in three years and Boston University in another three years. The law school a person went to isn't the sole determination of his or her legal abilities. It doesn't even determine if he or she will pass a state bar. Margret O'Shea went to Stanford University and Penn Law. She worked for the Department of Justice and for the Monterey County Public Defender, and had clerked for a US Court of Appeals judge. The big problem is that she wasn't licensed to be an attorney. She failed the California bar three times. How the hell could a Penn graduate who had the resume to get a Court of Appeals clerkship and a job at the DOJ not pass the California bar? Didn't she think she was going to get caught? Her state bar number should have been on any number of documents she submitted to a court. Did she make up one? You can look up attorneys by their state bar number on the California Bar Association website. Penn Law is a law school for which I would have killed babies, puppies, and old ladies, or sacrificed my own testicles, or listened to three hours a day, every day, of Sean Hannity, to be admitted. O'Shea was accepted there, got her JD, and really thought she could practice law without anyone noticing she had not passed the bar? Well, I guess she was right since the Department of Justice didn't notice and the Monterey County Public Defender hired her without noticing.
Not every embarrassing letter is by e-mail. A former Army Captain and Iraq and Afghanistan veteran applies to New York University School of Law. He is denied admission, probably due to his low undergraduate GPA and LSAT scores. So what's one to do? Retain counsel, of course! So Captain Nussbaum has his attorney send a letter to NYU, as well as carbon copying it to President Bush and Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, that he should be accepted because of his military experience, and that NYU might even have rejected him because of it. After all, those ivory towers of academia must hate the military, particularly if they don't let military recruiters on campus. Since minorities and women have been admitted to law school through affirmative action, why not do the same for veterans? Well, I will say that Captain Nussbaum certainly is thinking like a lawyer, though I don't know if that is grounds for admission to a top-tier law school. I also don't know about veterans being afforded the same protected class status as minorities or women.
Another thing you should have learned in law school is "Not cool" is not a legal argument. Kolve v. Cook, No. 2006AP1356, 2006 WL 3069538 n.4 (Wis. Ct. App. Oct. 31, 2006). I read about this footnote from both the Wall Street Journal Law Blog and Howard Bashman's How Appealing.
I guess all of this is a strong argument for those MCLE classes. One really never stops learning.
I've read stories of law clerks hooking up with associates. Particularly notorious are stories of young female law clerks working over the summer seducing senior partners, or is that the other way around? I usually consider such stories as reliable as locker-room talk since they mainly come from message boards such as Greedy Associates. However, a New Zealand law clerk removed all doubt when he e-mailed an associate at another firm with "At the end of the day we are both really busy and don't have time for anything else but a bit of good-hearted action . . . I thought you were hot and was sure you'd be a rocket in the sack, which I think you would be . . .." Do men honestly think that propositioning women in such a forward and vulgar manner would cause them to respond in the affirmative? Maybe that's what I'm doing wrong with women; I haven't made clear my desire to make the beast with two backs. William Shakespeare, Othello act 1, sc. 1.
For something stateside but still an example of how not to write e-mail, there was the infamous case of the exchange between two lawyers over a declining of a hiring offer. Diana Abdala took a year off after she graduated from Suffolk University Law in 2004. Then she started looking for a job and answered a Craigslist advertisement by William Korman for a new associate. Korman was going to hire two associates instead of one, so he had to lower his offer to her by $5,000. Korman said Abdala agreed to work for him despite the lower amount of money. Abdala said she made no agreement and was still pondering the offer. Anyways, Abdala sends an e-mail declining the offer because it won't support her and the lifestyle to which she is accustomed. Korman replies by e-mail that he had already created computer accounts and business cards for her and finds her behavior unprofessional. Rather than leave it at that, Abdala trots out a 1L answer that a contract should be in writing and that a real lawyer would not have acted in reliance until he had an written agreement. I guess she missed that part in Contracts about promissory estoppel and detrimental reliance, and what contracts the Statute of Frauds actually requires to be in writing. Korman, who has been a member of the bar for over a decade and is a former prosecutor was insulted at being called not a real lawyer, wrote back an e-mail chiding her for the law school answer and informs her that pissing off lawyers is not a good idea, particularly when she might be encountering those lawyers on a regular basis. Abdala's answer would make William Strunk proud, except for the misspelling: "Bla bla bla." Korman decides to forward this e-mail exchange and it gets forwarded and forwarded, so it spreads and makes the front page of the Boston Globe, and even Nightline. Sacha Pfeiffer, 2 E-mailers get testy, and hundreds read every word, BOSTON GLOBE, Feb. 16, 2006, at A1 available at 2006 WLNR 2693026; Nightline (ABC television broadcast Feb. 17, 2006). The Wall Street Journal Law Blog has the actual text of the e-mail exchange for the curious. She filed a complaint with the Massachusetts bar claiming that Korman forwarded their communication and was threatening her. To the Boston Globe, Abdala described herself as a "trust fund baby", and she certainly sounds like one. On the other hand, Korman was similarly immature by snidely responding back and forwarding their conversation to third parties. Any publicity is good publicity, but I think both parties are for the worse by having the e-mail exchange published.
By the way, the online commentary over the Abdala-Korman exchange again brings up the ugly head of law school ranking elitism. Harriet Miers went to SMU for law school, so she must have been too stupid to go a top tier law school, even if Chief Justice Warren Burger went to St. Paul College of Law, now William Mitchell College of Law, and Associate Justice Thurgood Marshall went to Howard University. Both of those are fourth-tier law schools. Suffolk is a fourth-tier law school, so obviously Abdala can not be brilliant though she she finished high school in three years and Boston University in another three years. The law school a person went to isn't the sole determination of his or her legal abilities. It doesn't even determine if he or she will pass a state bar. Margret O'Shea went to Stanford University and Penn Law. She worked for the Department of Justice and for the Monterey County Public Defender, and had clerked for a US Court of Appeals judge. The big problem is that she wasn't licensed to be an attorney. She failed the California bar three times. How the hell could a Penn graduate who had the resume to get a Court of Appeals clerkship and a job at the DOJ not pass the California bar? Didn't she think she was going to get caught? Her state bar number should have been on any number of documents she submitted to a court. Did she make up one? You can look up attorneys by their state bar number on the California Bar Association website. Penn Law is a law school for which I would have killed babies, puppies, and old ladies, or sacrificed my own testicles, or listened to three hours a day, every day, of Sean Hannity, to be admitted. O'Shea was accepted there, got her JD, and really thought she could practice law without anyone noticing she had not passed the bar? Well, I guess she was right since the Department of Justice didn't notice and the Monterey County Public Defender hired her without noticing.
Not every embarrassing letter is by e-mail. A former Army Captain and Iraq and Afghanistan veteran applies to New York University School of Law. He is denied admission, probably due to his low undergraduate GPA and LSAT scores. So what's one to do? Retain counsel, of course! So Captain Nussbaum has his attorney send a letter to NYU, as well as carbon copying it to President Bush and Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, that he should be accepted because of his military experience, and that NYU might even have rejected him because of it. After all, those ivory towers of academia must hate the military, particularly if they don't let military recruiters on campus. Since minorities and women have been admitted to law school through affirmative action, why not do the same for veterans? Well, I will say that Captain Nussbaum certainly is thinking like a lawyer, though I don't know if that is grounds for admission to a top-tier law school. I also don't know about veterans being afforded the same protected class status as minorities or women.
Another thing you should have learned in law school is "Not cool" is not a legal argument. Kolve v. Cook, No. 2006AP1356, 2006 WL 3069538 n.4 (Wis. Ct. App. Oct. 31, 2006). I read about this footnote from both the Wall Street Journal Law Blog and Howard Bashman's How Appealing.
I guess all of this is a strong argument for those MCLE classes. One really never stops learning.

2 Comments:
Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!
striving clerics motion punalur procure strength bangladeshi okalkanmeb puzzling moderate webquests
servimundos melifermuly
Post a Comment
<< Home