Pettifoggery

Pettifogger - 1) a lawyer whose methods are petty, underhanded, or disreputable 2) one given to quibbling over trifles

Name:
Location: The Wild and Woolly West, United States

Friday, December 08, 2006

You can't take the sky from me

Another long pedantic techy posts. Go ahead and ignore.

I wrote in an earlier post that I can't easily get television into my multi-dwelling unit (MDU). MDU is broadcast industry jargon for apartments, hotels, and condominiums. The airport is nearby so any over-the-air signal is out. Darn airport took the sky away from me. I actually bought some pretty good UHF-only antennas and tested them out. For San Diego-based stations, I only got snow. I actually could pick up Los Angeles-based stations better, though I would get a headache from watching them. My balcony faces the wrong way for a satellite dish, since DirecTV and DishNetwork's satellites sit over the equator, and I am very much north of the equator. I can't get cable because AT&T has an exclusive agreement with the building to provide telephone, internet, and television service. That means going through AT&T Home Entertainment is the only option to get television. Well, I finally broke down and ordered it.

AT&T Home Entertainment works a bit strangely. There is a single DirecTV dish on the top of the building, which feeds into the cable television wires into the building. So there's traditional television cable jacks in all of my rooms. I plug the satellite receiver into the jack. OK, it's not that strange. It just means I have a really really really long cable between the receiver and the satellite dish, and everyone else is connected to the satellite dish too. Even though it's DirecTV, it's through AT&T, so I don't get any of the DirecTV promotions, so no free receiver or discount on channel packages. AT&T also won't provide any digital video recorders (DVRs). I have to get one on my own.

There's a few additional hoops to jump through if you want an integrated receiver/DVR. DirecTV and Dishnetwork transmit their channels in MPEG-2 or MPEG-4. That means it's a digital stream. It's also why you see blockiness when you watch the channels. The receiver takes the digital signal and converts it to analog for your ordinary television. I have a separate standalone DVR, a TiVo Series 2. The TiVo takes the analog and converts it into digital MPEG-2 for storage on its hard drive. Then it converts the digital to analog for my television. So that means to get from the satellite through my TiVo to my satellite is digital to analog to digital to analog. Every time a conversion is made, there is a possible decrease in quality. It doesn't bother me because the output from the receiver looks crappy to my eyes. However, some people don't like it so they get a in integrated receiver/DVR. That means the same box is both a satellite receiver and a DVR. The DVR directly records the MPEG-2 or MPEG-4 that the satellite dish receives and then converts it to analog for the television, so that means it's only digital to analog. Also, there is no delay in channel changing. Changing the channel on my TiVo remote tells the TiVo to transmit an infrared change channel signal to the receiver, which actually adds a noticeable delay. Obviously, an integrated receiver/DVR doesn't have this delay. However, I can't just hook one up to the cable jack in my room. A traditional satellite-receiver hookup is actually multiple cables, because it's receiving multiple satellites. A satellite can only broadcast so much, so to get the 10,000 channels, multiple satellites are needed. One cable per satellite. That would get complicated quickly, so the signal is "stacked", meaning a single cable can carry two signals. The receiver then "de-stacks" it into two signals. Well, most satellite receivers have destackers. Most integrated receiver/DVRs don't. That means you have to buy a destacker, which is another $150, and it's something you can't buy at a local Fry's. Just easier just to buy a standalone DVR and deal with the minor degradation in quality and the delay in channel changing. TiVo is supposed to decrease my channel surfing anyways.

The stacking of cable also prevents any HD into my building. DirecTV offers HD service, though it requires an elliptical 18-inch by 24-inch dish instead of the ordinary 18-inch round dish, because it requires more satellites. HD signals suck up a lot of bandwidth. DirecTV HD service requires four satellites, which means four cables. That's two more than I can get. When the tech installed my receiver, he told me how AT&T offers DirecTV HD for other buildings. They still have the single cable but the signal is converted to QAM. QAM is a fancy-shmancy way that normal cable companies use to distribute bandwidth-hungry HD signals over a single cable. Obviously, a good thing, though it requires new tuners or set-top boxes. TiVo Series 3 and most currently sold HDTVs have a QAM tuner. If it has a CableCARD slot, it has a QAM tuner. CableCARD was a cable-industry solution to a FCC mandate. The FCC wanted people to get digital signals without having an extra set-top box. When the satellite or cable company broadcast channels, they broadcast every channel. Obviously, this doesn't work if you want different pricing packages for different sets of channels, so the channels are all encrypted. The set-top box or receiver is setup by the company to know which channels you receive and then decrypts the selected channels. The CableCard replaces the set-top box by also knowing which channels to decrypt.

OK, that's enough geeky information for now. I'm going to watch some C-SPAN. Yes, I really do watch C-SPAN.